Gottman's Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse: Criticism, Contempt, Defensiveness, Stonewalling

Criticism, Contempt, Defensiveness and Stonewalling erode trust, intimacy and connection in relationships

In any relationship, communication can either be a bridge to deeper connection or a barrier that breeds conflict. Renowned relationship researcher Dr John Gottman identified four specific communication styles that are particularly damaging — so much so that he called them The Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse. When these behaviours become regular visitors in a relationship, they can erode trust, intimacy, and connection. Let’s explore each horseman and understand why they matter.

1. Criticism: The First Horseman

Criticism goes beyond expressing a concern or complaint — it targets a person’s character. Instead of saying, “I’m upset that you didn’t help with the dishes,” criticism sounds more like, “You never help around the house. You’re so selfish.”

This kind of communication quickly turns a conversation into a personal attack. Unlike a complaint, which focuses on a specific behaviour and how it affects you, criticism is generalised, blaming, and accusatory. Over time, repeated criticism can make a partner feel rejected or devalued — the foundation of contempt.

2. Contempt: The Second Horseman

Contempt is criticism taken up a notch — it’s delivered with the intent to insult or emotionally wound. It may show up as sarcasm, mockery, name-calling, eye-rolling, or sneering. It communicates disgust and a sense of superiority over your partner.

This is the most dangerous of the four horsemen and is considered the single greatest predictor of relationship breakdown. Contempt doesn’t just hurt — it poisons. It builds up over time, often fed by unresolved issues and long-held resentments. When contempt enters a relationship, it becomes difficult to see your partner’s value or humanity.

Recognising contempt in ourselves requires courage and awareness. It often thrives when we’re too deep in emotional reactivity to notice its grip. But stepping back, taking a breath, and committing to a different path can change everything.

3. Defensiveness: The Third Horseman

When we feel criticised, it’s natural to want to defend ourselves. But defensiveness rarely leads to resolution. Instead, it escalates conflict by deflecting responsibility and turning the blame back on your partner.

For example, if your partner says, “I’m hurt you didn’t call,” a defensive response might be, “It's not a big deal, I was busy!”.  It may feel like self-protection, but it often communicates that you’re not willing to consider your partner’s feelings.

Defensiveness may be an instinctive response, but it prevents true understanding and accountability. When both partners become defensive, productive dialogue disappears.

4. Stonewalling: The Fourth Horseman

Stonewalling occurs when one partner shuts down and withdraws from interaction, often in response to feeling overwhelmed, criticised, or attacked. It’s the emotional equivalent of building a wall between you and your partner.

This might look like silent treatment, turning away, or walking out mid-conversation. Over time, stonewalling becomes a habit — a way to avoid conflict that ultimately creates more of it.

Stonewalling often begins as a protective mechanism. But the more we disengage, the harder it becomes to rebuild connection. Without communication, relationships stagnate — and healing becomes impossible.

Replacing the Horsemen

The good news? These destructive patterns aren’t destiny. Gottman’s research also offers antidotes to each horseman:

• Replace criticism with a gentle start-up: Express your feelings using “I” statements and focus on specific behaviours.

• Replace contempt with appreciation: Practice gratitude and respect — especially during tense moments.

• Replace defensiveness with responsibility: Even if it’s only a small part, acknowledge your role in the problem.

• Replace stonewalling with self-soothing: Take a break, calm down, and return when you’re ready to engage respectfully.

Final Thoughts

The four horsemen aren’t always easy to recognise — especially in the heat of conflict. But by learning to spot them and choosing more constructive ways to respond, we can strengthen our relationships and build deeper emotional intimacy. It starts with awareness, compassion, and the willingness to change course — even when it’s hard.

Want support in building a positive relationship? Click below.

Your Support Starts Here